Topic

Court rulings and payment deals in AI search

Short answer

Nobody is owed clicks from AI answers, and payment has only appeared where a legal claim forced it. On 1 October 2026 Judge Amit Mehta dismissed Penske Media's and Chegg's antitrust suits over AI Overviews, holding that expecting search traffic in return for content is not an agreement. In one market, press publishers hold a statutory claim, and Google agreed to separate AI reporting and payment tied to AI impressions there. Most businesses have no such claim. What they do have is their own controls, including a free Search Console setting that takes a site out of AI Overviews and AI Mode.

A judge dismissed the AI Overviews traffic suits. One market made Google pay on AI impressions. What each means for a business deciding what AI can show.

Read the lawsuit post first if you are deciding what to do with those controls. It says what each one does, why blocking Googlebot takes you out of Search as well, and why most businesses should stay eligible: an AI Overview that names you can still send someone to your door. It also says what could not be checked, because the order itself could not be read and the two reports on it disagree about whether the case can be refiled. The second post is smaller than its headline, and says so. Stop accepting that AI and classic reporting cannot be separated, because Google split them in that market, and know that an AI impression now has a negotiated price in one place. One small case study saw ordinary organic clicks fall after a site opted out, so measure before you flip the setting. NovaTechRay will not sell an opt-out service, because the lever is free.